Welcome to this sprawling 5+ bedroom colonial in historic E. Setauket in the renowned 3 Village School District. Set on .59 acres w/ fully fenced back yard and pool area. Offering 5 bathrooms, 3 car heated garage complimented with a 1/2-bathroom w/ 2nd door to the backyard for guests. Step outside to spend time on either of your 2 decks, pass the day swimming in the custom 22x44 cement, salt-water pool with LED lighting and water features, equipment updates through 2021 and new liner in '18. Solar panels cover all electric use, equipment payment of $409/mo with Mosaic Inc. Central air upgraded in '21. The living room boasts a red-brick wood burning fireplace, and the adjoining den with original red oak floors, LED high-hat lighting and platform are perfect for entertaining. Abutting your eat-in kitchen and dining room you'll find a laundry room, powder room and door leading to the garage. All 5 bedrooms are on the 2nd floor, with 2 full bathrooms. The fully finished basement is comprised of an exercise room, mechanical room with high efficiency boiler, storage and gorgeous 1 bedroom apartment with washer/dryer, split unit ac/heat, walk-in closet and separate patio for tenants or extended family. Tax grievance in process with Mark Lewis and STAR rebate of $1777. Come see your new home just blocks from Minnesauke Elementary and minutes from Stony Brook University, harbors and ample shopping., Additional information: Appearance:Diamond,Interior Features:Guest Quarters,Separate Hotwater Heater:Y